Research 2026-11-05 Conflict Management Fribourg

Conflict Management training in Fribourg"Doing It on Purpose": Attributing Hostile Intent at Work

"Doing It on Purpose": Attributing Hostile Intent at Work — SHR, Fribourg
"Doing It on Purpose": Attributing Hostile Intent at Work — SHR, Fribourg

A colleague does not respond to a message. A manager contests a proposal without explaining her reasoning. These behaviours are ambiguous, but their interpretation can become certain: "he is trying to put me in a difficult position". The hostile attribution bias consists of ascribing a hostile intention to ambiguous conduct. To examine it at work, this mechanism must be distinguished from the correspondence bias and from genuinely malicious disagreements.

1. What the Literature Establishes

Daniel T. Gilbert and Patrick S. Malone (1995, Psychological Bulletin) propose a synthesis of the correspondence bias: observers can infer personal dispositions from a behaviour even though situational constraints should limit this inference. Their analysis illuminates the passage from an observed fact to a judgement about the person. However, it does not specifically address hostile attribution in teams: inferring a trait and attributing an intention to harm remain two distinct operations. Gilbert & Malone, 1995 — The correspondence bias

2. The Neglected Distinction: Disagreement and Personal Attack

Tony L. Simons and Randall S. Peterson (2000, Journal of Applied Psychology) examine task conflict, relationship conflict and trust in top management teams. Intragroup trust moderates the association between the two forms of conflict: their relationship is less pronounced when trust is high. The authors interpret this result as supporting the hypothesis that disagreement about work can be wrongly attributed to personal opposition. It does not experimentally demonstrate that trust eliminates hostile intentions. Simons & Peterson, 2000 — Task conflict and relationship conflict in top management teams: The pivotal role of intragroup trust

"Doing It on Purpose": Attributing Hostile Intent at Work — Fribourg, Fribourg
"Doing It on Purpose": Attributing Hostile Intent at Work — Fribourg, Fribourg

3. Why Ambiguity Becomes an Intention

Observation and its interpretation can merge in a single sentence: "she rejected my proposal to discredit me". The rejection is observable; the purpose attributed to the colleague requires other elements. A role constraint, missing information or a different decision criterion constitute competing explanations to examine, not excuses to impose. The cited works make this separation relevant, but do not establish why a particular person interpreted a specific exchange as hostile.

4. The Limits of the Data

Gilbert and Malone's synthesis is neither an estimate of the frequency of hostile intentions at work nor a test of a mediation method. The Simons and Peterson study focuses on top management teams and relies on associations, not on an experimental manipulation of trust. It therefore does not allow one to assert that strengthening trust would cause a decrease in relationship conflicts in any team. Finally, genuine hostility, harassment or discrimination must not be requalified as a simple perceptual error. (our executive and employee training programmes)

5. Defensible Conditions for Practice

Before discussing the supposed intention, a cautious approach describes the behaviour, makes explicit its effect and poses a verifiable question about context. "The proposal was set aside without explanation; on what criterion?" opens a different investigation from "why do you want to block me?". One must preserve the possibility of genuinely problematic behaviour and document repeated facts. This framework constitutes a practical translation of the distinctions studied, not an intervention whose effectiveness the two articles would have demonstrated.

6. A Modest Pilot Study in Fribourg

During a debriefing in Fribourg, a team could select an ambiguous exchange with no disciplinary stakes and distinguish three elements: observable facts, the attributed intention and the information needed to verify it. It would then pose a clarification question to the person concerned, without requiring a benevolent interpretation. The review would focus on what was confirmed, corrected or left uncertain, not on a presumed decrease in conflicts. This work can be prepared in the SHR conflict management training To go further: explore the Conflict Management training in Fribourg in the canton of Fribourg, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.

In pictures: Conflict Management in Fribourg

Conflict Management training in Fribourg — in practice
Conflict Management training in Fribourg — in practice
Conflict Management training in Fribourg — hands-on workshop
Conflict Management training in Fribourg — hands-on workshop
Conflict Management training in Fribourg — on the ground
Conflict Management training in Fribourg — on the ground

Our training by canton