Frontline Management training in Geneva · canton of Genève"I believe in you": what managers' expectations actually produce

A manager is convinced that a colleague can progress and tells her so. A few weeks later, her results improve. This sequence suggests the Pygmalion effect: communicated expectations could themselves produce the expected performance. Two meta-analyses allow us to measure what research actually establishes, and what it does not allow us to claim.
1. What the literature establishes
Daniel B. McNatt (2000, Journal of Applied Psychology) brings together studies on the Pygmalion effect in organizations in a meta-analysis. The average effect appears positive and statistically significant: people from whom more is expected obtain, on average, better results than those from whom less is expected. McNatt discusses, however, the robustness of this result, notably the quality of the devices, the sensitivity to a few studies and the actual magnitude of the effect. The author concludes with a probable but fragile effect, and not a predictable law in every team. McNatt, 2000 — Pygmalion in work organizations: A meta-analysis
2. The neglected distinction: communicated expectation and private expectation
Nan Kierein and Malcolm N. Gold (2000, Journal of Organizational Behavior) in turn synthesize the literature. Their meta-analysis confirms a positive average effect of raising expectations on performance, but emphasizes that the mechanism assumes an expectation actually transmitted: it must be communicated, interpreted by the person concerned, then translate into different opportunities, resources or feedback. An internal conviction of the manager, never expressed, cannot by itself produce an effect. This distinction accounts for the expected conditions of the mechanism; it does not demonstrate that every stated expectation will be received as announced. Kierein & Gold, 2000 — Pygmalion in work organizations: A meta-analysis

3. Why encouragement alone is not enough
Telling someone that you judge them capable does not by itself change the conditions of their work. Without access to richer tasks, without room for maneuver, without precise feedback or right to fail, the stated expectation may remain a declaration. There is also a risk that the expectation becomes a pressure: if the expected performance is formulated as an obligation, the increase in the targeted result can be accompanied by increased tension, or even withdrawal. The articles cited do not examine this case and do not allow us to promise an always beneficial effect.
4. The limits of the data
The two meta-analyses concern heterogeneous studies, with variable tasks, durations and criteria, and sometimes fragile experimental devices. McNatt explicitly signals the sensitivity of the effect to the least rigorous studies. The measurements generally concern short-term results within a framework defined by the research. They say nothing about effects on well-being, on people whose expectations remain low, or on the equity of a selection based on initial impressions. Finally, they do not establish that a strong expectation would compensate for a lack of training or resources. (our executive and employee training programmes)
5. Defensible conditions for practice
A cautious approach combines the stated expectation with verifiable conditions: tasks corresponding to the intended level, support, regular feedback, explicit criteria. The manager can verify that the person has understood what is expected and what is offered to achieve it, rather than assuming that confidence is enough. They must also be able to lower the expectation without withdrawing it, when conditions change. These gestures reflect the communication condition highlighted by the two articles; they do not constitute a method whose effectiveness has been demonstrated.
6. A modest test in Geneva
A team in Geneva could compare two comparable situations: a person to whom an expectation has been communicated with corresponding resources, and another to whom the same expectation has been expressed without additional means. It would record what was said, what was made possible and what was subsequently observed, without concluding to a general effect. The exercise remains descriptive and does not measure any causality. It can be prepared in the SHR training in management skills To go further: explore the Frontline Management training in Geneva in the canton of Geneva, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.
In pictures: Frontline Management in Geneva



- frontline management
- Geneva
- research
- training geneva
Our training by canton
- GenevaFrontline Management
- VaudFrontline Management
- ZurichFrontline Management
- BernFrontline Management
- Basel-CityFrontline Management
- TicinoFrontline Management
- FribourgFrontline Management
- NeuchâtelFrontline Management
- LucerneFrontline Management
- St. GallenFrontline Management
- ValaisFrontline Management
- JuraFrontline Management
- ZugFrontline Management
