Research 2026-11-12 The Art of Feedback Sion

The Art of Feedback training in Sion · canton of Valais"I judge myself well": why self-assessment goes wrong

"I judge myself well": why self-assessment goes wrong — SHR, Sion
"I judge myself well": why self-assessment goes wrong — SHR, Sion

At the end of an exercise, two participants achieved very different results yet both estimated themselves above average. Self-assessment is not merely a lack of humility: it mobilizes the same competencies that need to be evaluated. A now-classic experiment and a large-scale synthesis help us understand this dual use, and the cases where the gap does not appear.

1. What the literature establishes

Justin Kruger and David Dunning (1999, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology) present several experiments in which participants are evaluated on logic, humour or grammar tasks, then invited to estimate their performance. People in the lower quartile markedly overestimate their result and often believe themselves to be above average. The authors advance a two-step explanation: the competencies needed to produce a good answer are also those that allow one to spot a bad answer, including one's own. After brief training on the task, the gap narrows, suggesting that the lack of awareness depended partly on the competency itself. Kruger & Dunning, 1999 — Unskilled and unaware of it: How difficulties in recognizing one's own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments

2. The overlooked distinction: estimation error and overconfidence

David Dunning, Chip Heath, Jerry Suls and Barbara M. Feld (2004, Psychological Science in the Public Interest) provide a broad synthesis of work on deficient self-assessment. The phenomenon is documented in health, education and work, but it is not universal: it depends on the nature of the task, the available criteria and the way people are invited to judge themselves. The synthesis also discusses the fact that highly competent people can underestimate themselves, and that an estimation error does not mean a person rejects information or lacks good faith. Dunning, Heath, Suls & Feld, 2004 — Flawed self-assessment: Implications for health, education, and the workplace

"I judge myself well": why self-assessment goes wrong — Sion, Valais
"I judge myself well": why self-assessment goes wrong — Sion, Valais

3. Why detail does not provide protection

Asking someone to rate themselves on a scale does not produce a reliable measure: it produces an opinion, whose quality depends on the ability to perceive one's own errors. Very detailed feedback given to someone who lacks the criteria to interpret it can even reinforce an illusion of mastery, by giving the impression that everything has been covered. The issue is therefore not to add lines to a self-assessment grid, but to expose the person to external references: comparisons, examples, explicit criteria.

4. The limitations of the data

Kruger and Dunning's experiments deal with short tasks immediately corrected in the laboratory with students; they do not transfer directly to a complex profession where performance is judged over several months. The synthesis by Dunning and his co-authors brings together very different fields and recalls that certain conditions attenuate the phenomenon, for example when criteria are clear or when the person has reason to seek accuracy. Finally, this work in no way justifies disqualifying a person's view of their work, nor replacing dialogue with a test. (our executive and employee training programmes)

5. Defensible conditions for practice

A prudent approach does not eliminate self-assessment: it grounds it in external elements. Concretely: precede self-assessment with an explanation of criteria, confront the two estimates without confusing them, and clearly distinguish what is a feeling from what is a measured performance. Feedback then becomes more useful, as it addresses identifiable gaps rather than impressions. These proposals reflect the mechanisms described; the articles cited do not demonstrate that they systematically improve performance.

6. A modest trial in Sion

A team in Sion could, before an interview, ask each person to estimate a specific aspect of their work over the past three months, then cite the elements on which the estimate is based. After comparing these elements with available data, they would note which criteria were underestimated or overvalued, and whether the simple obligation to cite evidence modified the estimate. The exercise remains descriptive and demonstrates no causal effect. It can be discussed in the SHR training in the art of feedback To go further: explore the The Art of Feedback training in Sion in the canton of Valais, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.

In pictures: The Art of Feedback in Sion

The Art of Feedback training in Sion — in practice
The Art of Feedback training in Sion — in practice
The Art of Feedback training in Sion — hands-on workshop
The Art of Feedback training in Sion — hands-on workshop
The Art of Feedback training in Sion — on the ground
The Art of Feedback training in Sion — on the ground

Our training by canton