Executive Leadership training in Fribourg"I don't know": What a leader's humility does

A leader publicly corrects one of his statements and asks for help on a subject he does not master. Some see a loss of authority; others, an opening. Research on expressed humility attempts to describe what this gesture actually produces — and under what conditions. Two articles allow us to understand the mechanisms and boundaries.
1. What the literature establishes
Bradley P. Owens, David R. Johnson and Todd B. Mitchell (2013, Organization Science) define expressed humility as a set of observable behaviors: acknowledging one's limitations, recognizing the contributions of others, welcoming feedback and errors. Drawing on qualitative and quantitative studies, they link these behaviors to a climate of psychological safety, better coordination and team results, and discuss their effect on succession and talent development. The authors emphasize that these links are associative: they do not demonstrate that humility mechanically causes performance. Owens, Johnson & Mitchell, 2013 — Expressed Humility in Organizations: Implications for Performance, Teams, and Leadership
2. The neglected distinction: humility and lack of character
Bradley P. Owens and David R. Hekman (2012, Academy of Management Journal) inductively examine leaders in healthcare services and describe humble behaviors, the challenges they raise and the outcomes achieved. Their analysis shows that these behaviors are costly and ambiguous: they can be read by teams as uncertainty, and by hierarchy as lack of confidence, to the point that leaders must learn to calibrate what they expose and to whom. Humility is therefore neither a comfortable posture nor the absence of direction: it requires judgment about the appropriate time and channel. Owens & Hekman, 2012 — Modeling How to Grow: An Inductive Examination of Humble Leader Behaviors, Challenges, and Outcomes

3. Why detail does not protect
A highly formalized culture can imitate humility without producing it: mandatory retrospectives, ritualized admissions of flaws, improvement forms. What matters is not how many times the leader says "I was wrong," but the consistency between his admissions and his decisions. Acknowledging an error and then systematically attributing failures to teams cancels the gesture. Expressed humility becomes credible when accompanied by a visible consequence: a decision revisited, a resource reallocated, a priority changed.
4. The limits of data
The two studies rely on particular samples: production and engineering teams for one, healthcare managers for the other, in a North American context. The measured links are associative and unobserved variables may explain them. The inductive study identifies challenges, not remedies: it does not guarantee that humble behavior will be well received in every corporate culture. Finally, the articles do not allow us to conclude that a leader must expose everything, nor that personal frankness is sufficient to correct an unequal power structure. (our executive and employee training programmes)
5. Defensible conditions for practice
A cautious approach distinguishes acknowledgment from repair. The leader can recognize a limitation and name in the same move what he does to address it: seeking competent advice, designating a person to correct, reconsidering a decision. Humility gains by being specific rather than general — an identified error is better than vague self-criticism. It also requires verifying whether people actually have the ability to contradict without risk. These proposals reflect the described mechanisms; they do not constitute a method whose effectiveness has been demonstrated.
6. A modest trial in Fribourg
A team in Fribourg could review a recent decision that the manager wished to correct and note what was said, what was changed and what was asked of those involved. It would then verify whether members were actually able to intervene before the change, or only after. The exercise remains descriptive and demonstrates no causal effect. It can be prepared in the SHR training in excellence leadership To go further: explore the Executive Leadership training in Fribourg in the canton of Fribourg, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.
In pictures: Executive Leadership in Fribourg



- executive leadership
- Fribourg
- research
- training fribourg
Our training by canton
- FribourgLeadership Excellence
- GenevaLeadership Excellence
- VaudLeadership Excellence
- ZurichLeadership Excellence
- BernLeadership Excellence
- Basel-CityLeadership Excellence
- TicinoLeadership Excellence
- NeuchâtelLeadership Excellence
- LucerneLeadership Excellence
- St. GallenLeadership Excellence
- ValaisLeadership Excellence
- JuraLeadership Excellence
- ZugLeadership Excellence
