Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel"This is not the right time": The invisible rules of silence

"This is not the right time": The invisible rules of silence — SHR, Neuchâtel
"This is not the right time": The invisible rules of silence — SHR, Neuchâtel

An employee had prepared an objection, then kept silent during the meeting. She was not afraid of explicit consequences: she simply judged that it was not "the right time", nor "the right way". These quick judgments resemble learned rules. A literature review and qualitative study make them visible and measure what research allows us to conclude.

1. What the literature establishes

Evan W. Morrison (2014, Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior) reviews employee voice and silence. Silence is frequent and rarely accidental: it results from risk assessment, perception of climate and signals given by management. The review distinguishes withdrawal silence, motivated by fear of consequences, from other forms of withholding, and emphasizes that organizations themselves produce these assessments through their practices, past reactions and observed precedents. Morrison does not present silence as an individual character trait. Morrison, 2014 — Employee voice and silence

2. The neglected distinction: calculated fear and implicit rule

Jay R. Detert and Amy C. Edmondson (2011, Academy of Management Journal) identify what they call implicit voice theories: rules taken for granted that make certain interventions unthinkable without having weighed them — not contradicting the superior in front of others, not challenging the meeting framework, not speaking about what remains unresolved. These rules have been learned, often in childhood or in a previous organization, and function as self-evident truths rather than as decisions. The qualitative study does not measure the frequency of these rules or their effect on performance. Detert & Edmondson, 2011 — Implicit voice theories: Taken-for-granted rules of self-censorship at work

"This is not the right time": The invisible rules of silence — Neuchâtel, Neuchâtel
"This is not the right time": The invisible rules of silence — Neuchâtel, Neuchâtel

3. Why detail does not protect

Formally inviting to "raise issues" is not enough to lift an implicit rule: the person does not perceive that a rule is holding them back, they simply perceive that the intervention seems impossible or improper to them. An anonymous channel may therefore remain unused, and a highly structured meeting does not prevent silence if precedents have shown that an objection was costly. The decisive point is not the existence of a mechanism but the consistency between what is asked and what is actually tolerated.

4. The limits of the data

Morrison's review aggregates work using very diverse methods and does not allow isolating a single cause of silence, nor affirming that more voice would automatically improve results. The Detert and Edmondson study is qualitative, with a limited sample: it identifies mechanisms, not frequencies, and does not show that a particular managerial intervention would make them disappear. Finally, some withholding is legitimate: silence can protect sensitive information or reflect a priority trade-off, and should not be treated as a deficit to correct in all cases. (our executive and employee training programmes)

5. Defensible conditions for practice

A cautious approach consists of making rules explicit rather than demanding frankness. The manager can state what is welcome, in what framework, at what time and with what actual consequences; they can also name their own past reactions and acknowledge those that discouraged participation. Asking for a precise objection on a precise point, rather than a general opinion, reduces inference effort. These gestures translate the mechanisms described by both articles; they do not constitute a method whose effectiveness has been demonstrated.

6. A modest test in Neuchâtel

A team in Neuchâtel could revisit a recent meeting in which an important subject was not discussed, and ask each person, separately, what would have made an intervention difficult. The responses would then be classified between feared consequences, rules considered self-evident and simple scheduling questions. The exercise remains descriptive, measures no causal effect and should not be used to identify who remained silent. It can be prepared within the SHR training on the relationship with one's manager To go further: explore the Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel in the canton of Neuchâtel, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.

In pictures: Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager in Neuchâtel

Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel — in practice
Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel — in practice
Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel — hands-on workshop
Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel — hands-on workshop
Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel — on the ground
Building an Effective Relationship with Your Manager training in Neuchâtel — on the ground

Our training by canton