Complex Management training in Lausanne · canton of VaudTwo Managers, Two Priorities: Distinguishing Role Ambiguity from Role Conflict

A project manager asks to preserve the scope; a functional manager asks to reassign the same people. The employee sometimes knows both expectations perfectly well, but cannot satisfy them together. In another situation, no one specifies who can authorize the reassignment. These difficulties call for different responses. Literature on roles provides useful vocabulary to avoid treating every matrix tension as a communication failure.
1. What the literature establishes
John R. Rizzo, Robert J. House and Sidney I. Lirtzman (1970, Administrative Science Quarterly) develop measures of role conflict and role ambiguity in complex organizations. Ambiguity concerns notably uncertainty about responsibilities, expectations or authority; conflict refers to incompatible demands. Their organizational data support the value of distinguishing these dimensions, without establishing that a matrix structure necessarily provokes them. Rizzo, House & Lirtzman, 1970 — Role Conflict and Ambiguity in Complex Organizations
2. The neglected distinction: ambiguity and incompatibility
Travis C. Tubre and Judith M. Collins (2000, Journal of Management) synthesize correlations between these dimensions and job performance. Their meta-analysis finds a negative association between ambiguity and performance, whereas the association between role conflict and performance is weak. Type of job and source of evaluation moderate the relationship concerning ambiguity. These results allow neither assimilating the two difficulties nor considering conflict as harmless for all other job outcomes. Tubre & Collins, 2000 — Jackson and Schuler (1985) Revisited: A Meta-Analysis of the Relationships Between Role Ambiguity, Role Conflict, and Job Performance

3. Why detail does not protect
A detailed job description can clarify responsibilities without resolving an incompatibility between two legitimate demands. Conversely, an arbitration meeting does not necessarily clarify a person's evaluation criteria. In a matrix, the useful question thus becomes: is there missing information about the role, or a decision between already-known expectations? This reading is an application of concepts, not a result demonstrated for all matrix organizations.
4. The limits of data
The initial study concerns particular organizations and relies on self-reported measures of roles. The meta-analysis brings together mainly correlational relationships: it does not demonstrate that reducing ambiguity increases performance. Performance evaluations and work situations differ between studies. Finally, these articles do not directly compare all variants of matrix structures; they do not allow choosing a universally superior organizational chart. (our executive and employee training programmes)
5. Defensible conditions for practice
A cautious approach separates two registers. For ambiguity, it makes explicit the expected result, the decision scope and the person who evaluates the work. For conflict, it designates an arbitration body and makes explicit the priority retained when two demands cannot be satisfied together. These proposals translate the theoretical distinction; the cited articles do not demonstrate the effectiveness of this particular arrangement.
6. A modest test in Lausanne
In a team in Lausanne, two managers could examine with an employee a recent blocked decision. They separately record what was unknown and what was incompatible, then clarify either missing information or an arbitration rule. At the next comparable decision, they note whether the same difficulty returns. This local observation does not prove a causal effect and may reveal another constraint. The approach can be discussed in SHR training in complex management To go further: explore the Complex Management training in Lausanne in the canton of Vaud, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.
In pictures: Complex Management in Lausanne



- complex management
- Lausanne
- research
- training lausanne
Our training by canton
- VaudManaging Complexity
- GenevaManaging Complexity
- ZurichManaging Complexity
- BernManaging Complexity
- Basel-CityManaging Complexity
- TicinoManaging Complexity
- FribourgManaging Complexity
- NeuchâtelManaging Complexity
- LucerneManaging Complexity
- St. GallenManaging Complexity
- ValaisManaging Complexity
- JuraManaging Complexity
- ZugManaging Complexity
